Are you growing your cacti in a soilless mix?

Discuss repotting, soil, lighting, fertilizing, watering, etc. in this category.
User avatar
ChaoticN
Posts: 29
Joined: Tue Jul 18, 2023 6:52 pm
Location: Kentucky / Zone 6b

Re: Are you growing your cacti in a soilless mix?

Post by ChaoticN »

The raised bed mix from my area only has decomposed leaf an wood chip according to the ingredients labeling on the bag. It could be a locality thing.

I’ll post a pic here in a bit for you, I work in a garden center but it could take me a little bit were I have to resize the photo to be allowed on here.
Attachments
IMG_2024-05-15-221713.jpeg
IMG_2024-05-15-221713.jpeg (176.41 KiB) Viewed 3220 times
Zone 6B, Kentucky. 860ft Elevation.
User avatar
ChaoticN
Posts: 29
Joined: Tue Jul 18, 2023 6:52 pm
Location: Kentucky / Zone 6b

Re: Are you growing your cacti in a soilless mix?

Post by ChaoticN »

This is the all purpose mix, I’m not sure about what there selling now cause the ingredients may have changed.
Zone 6B, Kentucky. 860ft Elevation.
User avatar
Steve Johnson
Posts: 4755
Joined: Thu Nov 03, 2011 4:44 am
Location: Los Angeles, CA (Zone 10b)

Re: Are you growing your cacti in a soilless mix?

Post by Steve Johnson »

ChaoticN wrote: Mon May 13, 2024 8:06 pm The raised bed mix from my area only has decomposed leaf an wood chip according to the ingredients labeling on the bag. It could be a locality thing.

I’ll post a pic here in a bit for you, I work in a garden center but it could take me a little bit were I have to resize the photo to be allowed on here.
Just saw your photo, and something jumped out at me...

In the quest for a soilless mix with organic material, shredded or finely chipped pine/fir bark holds out a lot of promise as the one and only organic component to use. John Trager of the Huntington Botanical Garden's desert greenhouse used a a well-composted pine and fir bark medium. But as he said, "It worked well enough but became quite hydrophobic when dry." Your Back to the Roots product includes yucca extract as a wetting agent. While I wouldn't recommend Back to the Roots, I think shredded or finely chipped bark plus yucca extract may be worth trying. Check this out:

https://www.amazon.com/Extract-Organic- ... 5533&psc=1

The idea here is to keep it simple -- one ingredient on the mineral side and one ingredient on the organic side. If yucca extract is effective as a wetting agent, give pine or fir bark a shot and you'll have the right organic to go with your mineral.
If you just want photos without all the blather, please visit my Flickr gallery.
My location: Los Angeles, CA (Zone 10b)
User avatar
ChaoticN
Posts: 29
Joined: Tue Jul 18, 2023 6:52 pm
Location: Kentucky / Zone 6b

Re: Are you growing your cacti in a soilless mix?

Post by ChaoticN »

I haven’t had that problem so far but I am adding in quite a bit of 1/8” akadama and 1/4” pumice. The mix feels like it”s about 35% worm castings 40% fully decomposed leaf matter and about 10% wood fines and like 15% orchid bark.
Zone 6B, Kentucky. 860ft Elevation.
AirWreck
Posts: 54
Joined: Fri Apr 12, 2024 1:55 am
Location: Appalachian Piedmont (zone 7a)

Re: Are you growing your cacti in a soilless mix?

Post by AirWreck »

TBH, I'm hesitant to use anything conifer related for an organic component because exposure to pine needles falling from a pine tree overhanging my apartment balcony is what initially infected my collection with rust fungus. I lost half my plants from that event, including all of my Ariocarpus. Its been 20 years on now and I'm still grappling with rust fungus though it is on the wane. Cedars are a known host for rust fungus. That's why, for example, you can't have cedars near your apple trees. Last thing I want to do is inoculate my soil mix with rust fungus spores. I don't want this to happen to someone else. Assess your conifer derived product well before using it is what I recommend as some people find no problems with using it. I wouldn't trust anything in my area. So, I need something else if anything organic is to be used. On that note, please read the next paragraphs below.

If a "well composted" something is recommended, then why not worm castings or mushroom compost? Currently, I'm trying out worm castings. I'm assuming they offer active and balanced microbiota. My concern with worm castings or mushroom compost is longevity. How long will it be a contributing ingredient in the soil mix after potting up? Does it break down and wash away in a couple months or does it continue to contribute for a couple years? I know of a Thai cactus grower who personally composts leaves from a certain tree in his country and that is the sole organic component of his soil mix. Do a search for "Mr. Baso" on youtube. His plants are stunning! Some of the videos have English subtitles. I learned a lot about root trimming as a prevention for root rot from his videos.

Or as the thread title suggests "soilless mix" thereby indicating "none of the above" organic materials? I'm totally down for soilless, or perhaps better said organicless, if I can learn how to make it work on the long term using materials available to me. My current materials on hand are expanded slate, pumice, lava rock, turface and coarse sharp sand for the structural component of my soil mix. Fertlizer, trace minerals, and acidified water are the nutrient components for the nutritional regimen of my plants. I'm currently working all this out as I am currently redeveloping how I'm caring for my cactus plants. So, I really can't say much more as its still rather up in the air.
User avatar
ChaoticN
Posts: 29
Joined: Tue Jul 18, 2023 6:52 pm
Location: Kentucky / Zone 6b

Re: Are you growing your cacti in a soilless mix?

Post by ChaoticN »

If you can go pure mineral that’s what I would do, the organic bit is really only for certain species, mainly jungle types.
Zone 6B, Kentucky. 860ft Elevation.
User avatar
Steve Johnson
Posts: 4755
Joined: Thu Nov 03, 2011 4:44 am
Location: Los Angeles, CA (Zone 10b)

Re: Are you growing your cacti in a soilless mix?

Post by Steve Johnson »

This is my 60% pumice-40% granite gravel mix:
Pumice-DG_rinsed04242016_forum.jpg
Pumice-DG_rinsed04242016_forum.jpg (201.76 KiB) Viewed 3135 times
Grain sizes range from 1 mm to 5 mm. The mix provides wide-open aeration to the roots, and cactus roots thrive in it. Not the best for growers living in arid climates, although they may be able to do well with nothing but pumice -- any members out there having success with that?

I'm now of the opinion that completely inorganic soilless mixes are the best way to go for this reason:
  • Coarse organic materials (like tree bark and sphagnum peat) eventually break down and turn into slush, inviting pathogens to come in and have fun at your and your plants' expense.
Only way to avoid the problem is by repotting with fresh mix every 3 years or so. Call me lazy, but I'm in favor of repotting cacti only when they outgrow their pots and need a bigger pot. Speaking from personal experience, that's a nice problem to have! As I've mentioned in earlier posts, the only downside with pure mineral mixes is that cacti need to be fertilized every time they're watered in the growing season. But worth the effort when you enjoy seeing healthy well-grown cacti year after year. With that said, some cactus species do need to have soil in the mix. 2 genera which apply are Echinopsis and Trichocereus, so be sure that you know which cacti are or aren't suited to growing in a pure soilless mineral mix.
If you just want photos without all the blather, please visit my Flickr gallery.
My location: Los Angeles, CA (Zone 10b)
SpriteFish
Posts: 52
Joined: Sat May 11, 2024 12:05 am
Location: Wellington, New Zealand. 70 - 80% humidity

Re: Are you growing your cacti in a soilless mix?

Post by SpriteFish »

What's the ideal grain size for pumice and gravel in this mix (Also does this change in a mix with soil)? I see that yours is between 1mm-5mm but are there any drawbacks to using slightly larger sizes (e.g. 5mm - 10mm grains)?
Wellington, New Zealand.

Humidity 70% - 80%, goes as low as 60%.
User avatar
Steve Johnson
Posts: 4755
Joined: Thu Nov 03, 2011 4:44 am
Location: Los Angeles, CA (Zone 10b)

Re: Are you growing your cacti in a soilless mix?

Post by Steve Johnson »

SpriteFish wrote: Sat May 25, 2024 2:40 amI see that yours is between 1mm-5mm but are there any drawbacks to using slightly larger sizes (e.g. 5mm - 10mm grains)?
5 mm-10 mm is quite a bit larger -- too open for a soilless mix. I grow 4 of my cacti in a 50% pumice/50% soil mix, so I'd recommend pumice with 3 mm-5 mm grains. It also depends on the size of the plant. If you have cacti in really big pots, you might be able to go with 5 mm-10 mm pumice in a pumice and soil mix. IMO 1 mm-5 mm is ideal for pure mineral soilless mixes regardless of pot size.
If you just want photos without all the blather, please visit my Flickr gallery.
My location: Los Angeles, CA (Zone 10b)
User avatar
Steve Johnson
Posts: 4755
Joined: Thu Nov 03, 2011 4:44 am
Location: Los Angeles, CA (Zone 10b)

Re: Are you growing your cacti in a soilless mix?

Post by Steve Johnson »

I'll have to correct myself on something I said:
Steve Johnson wrote: Fri May 17, 2024 12:19 am
  • Coarse organic materials (like tree bark and sphagnum peat) eventually break down and turn into slush, inviting pathogens to come in and have fun at your and your plants' expense.
Here's the correction:
MikeInOz wrote: Sun Jan 28, 2024 11:33 pmOrganic material does NOT cause disease of any kind. Pathogenic organisms do. Pathogens do not ''come with'' organic material. They are everywhere including the computer screen you are looking at right now, all over your clothes and even in the dust in the air. All they need is food and the correct environment...So what is the problem with organic? Well it breaks down and as it does, water holding capacity goes up and air-filled porosity goes down. That can benefit some (but not all) pathogens. It is the same as using very fine mineral components to the mix. Therefore, using organic materials will be more acceptable for... plants which can tolerate slower drying in the mix (eventually), small pots, watering frequency which is low. Organic materials will be less acceptable for plants which do not like slowly increasing water holding capacity, large pots and watering frequency which is high.
AirWreck posted a couple of good points, and they're worth repeating:
AirWreck wrote: Thu May 16, 2024 12:43 pmCedars are a known host for rust fungus. That's why, for example, you can't have cedars near your apple trees...Assess your conifer derived product well before using it is what I recommend as some people find no problems with using it. I wouldn't trust anything in my area...as the thread title suggests "soilless mix" thereby indicating "none of the above" organic materials?
The first point is really important, although composted pine and fir bark have been known to work well as the organic component for a number of growers. John Trager of the Huntington Botanical Garden's desert greenhouse used a mix of 80% pumice and 20% of that compost -- worked well until he found out that it became hydrophobic after repeated wet-dry cycles. Unfortunately he didn't investigate wetting agents, so I wanted to investigate this myself -- not for me, but for growers who might want to try something like what Mr. Trager did. Let's ask our cactus horticulturalist-in-residence:
MikeInOz wrote: Sat May 25, 2024 7:56 am
Steve Johnson wrote: Sat May 25, 2024 6:55 am
MikeInOz wrote: Sat May 25, 2024 6:08 am New Zealand is where Orchiata bark comes from. They have a seedling grade (called ''Precision'') which is 3-6 mm. You can use that...
Only problem with any sort of tree bark is that it becomes hydrophobic after repeated wet-dry cycles. A wetting agent takes care of the problem, and I've read that yucca extract is a good one. We can find it here in the US, but I don't know about Australia and New Zealand. If yucca extract for plants isn't available there, would you recommend other wetting agents that'll work for growing cacti and succulents?
Yes. I use a commercial wetting agent. It's lasts the entire growing season. I would not recommend any of the organic types. Many have been found to not last long and to actually make things worse in some cases. I use it every year on many plants but still have not used it on cacti but I did notice some plants which were not potted for a while had difficulty absorbing water so next season I will try it out. It's important not to use too much and only do it once.
I use this. https://www.bunnings.com.au/amgrow-1l-w ... t_p3010119
I am sure there are similar products in the US
I'll leave this line of inquiry up to those of you who'd like to investigate further.

AirWreck's 2nd point gave me an idea on how we can more accurately describe different types of soilless mix:
  • Organic soilless -- mineral gravel and coarse organic material. I'm pretty sure that we're talking about composts (maybe a loose definition?) which eventually break down into soil, and this is where the 1st quote from Mike comes into play. Compared to soil-based mixes, I think it'll take longer for the breakdown to get bad enough that water-holding capacity is unacceptably long. How long will depend on what growers experience, and the tricky part is knowing when they have to repot cacti with fresh mix. I can't see any way around having to go through some trial-and-error on this one.
  • Inorganic soilless -- pure mineral gravel. Not only are its benefits significant, this is a low-maintenance mix because the gravels last forever. (Slight exaggeration, but pumice and calcined clay granules take a really long time to break down.)
Whether soilless mixes can or can't be used will depend on the species, so I'll break this down into 2 basic habitat types:
  • Cacti native to North American and South American deserts -- soilless mixes. The only exception I can find involves cacti with very thin fibrous roots, and the Tephros I grow are examples -- they need a 50% pumice/50% soil mix.
  • Cacti native to grasslands -- these species need a substantial amount of organic material, and their roots won't grow well in soilless mixes.
The 2 genera I mentioned in a previous post are Echinopsis and Trichocereus, both are native to grassland habitats, so what should we do about finding a suitable soil? I used to think that a lot of commercial potting soils are garbage because they're way too rich in organic materials for cacti. Mike corrected me (and by extension our other members) on the matter, hence my reason for posting his 1st quote -- maybe commercial potting soils aren't so bad after all. In fact, our US members might have just the right stuff:

https://www.amazon.com/Rosy-Soil-Cactus ... hdGY&psc=1

My default recommendation for soil-based mixes is 50% mineral gravel and 50% soil. Even though I don't have any experience with Echinopsis or Trichocereus, it's possible that you can tilt the mix more in favor of soil with a 40/60 mineral gravel and soil mix if you grow them. Based on what I saw with the ingredients listed, Rosy Soil holds a lot of promise. If any of our members decide to try it, I'd like to hear about their experiences good or bad after they've been using it for awhile.
If you just want photos without all the blather, please visit my Flickr gallery.
My location: Los Angeles, CA (Zone 10b)
AirWreck
Posts: 54
Joined: Fri Apr 12, 2024 1:55 am
Location: Appalachian Piedmont (zone 7a)

Re: Are you growing your cacti in a soilless mix?

Post by AirWreck »

I'm totally down for standardizing terminology- helps to reduce confusion. However, its too early in the morning for me to offer any suggestions.

Imo, soil is whatever you are putting into the pot whether mineral or organic, or a mix of the two- that's your "potting soil". And we should be clear that, by saying "organic", we are using that term in the chemical sense that the material is carbon based. We are not using it in the sense of organic agricultural processes.

We have a saying around here about the agricultural quality of one's soil. That is: "Don't let your soil turn into dirt." That is because soil will grow plants; dirt won't.
SpriteFish
Posts: 52
Joined: Sat May 11, 2024 12:05 am
Location: Wellington, New Zealand. 70 - 80% humidity

Re: Are you growing your cacti in a soilless mix?

Post by SpriteFish »

The only caveat I make regarding soil-less mixes is the fact that some species' root systems won't grow well in them, as I noted in one of my posts from February 12. That'll be the post involving photos of my Tephros. But for a lot of desert species, I highly recommend going soil-less/hydroponic whenever possible.
Why might a plant grow better in a hydroponic mix aside from more protection from overwatering? Also I'm curious if you know why you found that plants in soil had poor root systems, yet when put into the hydroponic mix they grey better. Not at all questioning the improvement, just wanting to learn :D. I'm curious what about loam allows plants with thinner fibrous roots to grow better, prephaphs it's structure and consistency?
Wellington, New Zealand.

Humidity 70% - 80%, goes as low as 60%.
User avatar
Steve Johnson
Posts: 4755
Joined: Thu Nov 03, 2011 4:44 am
Location: Los Angeles, CA (Zone 10b)

Re: Are you growing your cacti in a soilless mix?

Post by Steve Johnson »

SpriteFish wrote: Wed Jun 12, 2024 4:59 amWhy might a plant grow better in a hydroponic mix aside from more protection from overwatering?
We're talking about desert cacti specifically, not plants in general. Drainage and aeration go hand-in-hand, so I'll give your two extremes -- one bad and one good as they pertain to growing desert cacti under pot cultivation:
  • The bad extreme -- the mix is mostly or entirely soil. This is a "custom" cactus mix I got from the California Cactus Center in Pasadena when I began my current collection in 2011:
    CCC_soil_sample.JPG
    CCC_soil_sample.JPG (123.25 KiB) Viewed 2643 times
    Mostly soil. The owners recommended adding pumice, but just for a handful of the species I purchased there. When I watered the cacti that were only in their mix, it took a few minutes for the water to drain down out of each pot's drain hole. Drainage was poor, and the roots were being slowly suffocated by the soil. Even worse, the mix was taking too long to dry out and I didn't even know it. When I moved these cacti from the CCC mix to the hydroponic pumice and granite gravel mix I started using in spring 2012, I was shocked by how underdeveloped their roots were. In fact, a few cacti lost their roots entirely, and they never recovered.
  • The good extreme -- with the hydroponic mix, water drains all the way through in a matter of seconds. Excellent drainage and wide-open aeration led to the kind of robust, healthy root growth which made a huge improvement in the collection's overall growing quality. Add the fertilizer regimen I started last year, and the quality gains are continuing.
I should also mention that my approach is semi-hydroponic because the roots of my cacti need to go from wet to bone-dry between waterings. In a fully hydroponic system, nonxeric plants are given a constant supply of water and nutrients.
SpriteFish wrote: Wed Jun 12, 2024 4:59 amI'm curious what about loam allows plants with thinner fibrous roots to grow better, prephaphs it's structure and consistency?
Once again, we're talking specifically about desert cacti. I mentioned the fact that the roots of my Tephros couldn't be supported in the hydroponic mix, and I'll show you why:
Tephrocactus_articulatus_var_papyracanthus_Jr&Sr03162013.jpg
Tephrocactus_articulatus_var_papyracanthus_Jr&Sr03162013.jpg (162.82 KiB) Viewed 2643 times
That's Tephrocactus papyracanthus after a year of being in the hydroponic mix. Notice how thin and scraggly the roots are -- should've had much more of a root system.
Tephrocactus_articulatus_var_inermis03172013.JPG
Tephrocactus_articulatus_var_inermis03172013.JPG (94.6 KiB) Viewed 2643 times
The roots of the Tephro inermis looked a little better, but not by much. I still had a lot to learn. If it weren't for advice I got from a more experienced grower on the forum, I would've kept my Tephros in the hydroponic mix and wondered why they would continue to struggle. But his advice was spot-on -- the plants really perked up when I moved them to a 50% pumice-50% soil mix in 2013. When I water them, water drains through in about 15 seconds, so they're getting the right balance between soil and mineral. IMO it's a suitable mix for all Opuntioids, not just Tephrocactus.
If you just want photos without all the blather, please visit my Flickr gallery.
My location: Los Angeles, CA (Zone 10b)
AirWreck
Posts: 54
Joined: Fri Apr 12, 2024 1:55 am
Location: Appalachian Piedmont (zone 7a)

Re: Are you growing your cacti in a soilless mix?

Post by AirWreck »

I just wanted to point out to people for the sake of clarification that, when we are saying hydroponic mix, we're being a bit tongue in cheek. True hydroponic growing implies a daily ebb and flow cycle of water and fertilizer. We aren't doing that. What we are saying is that the soil mix has no organic component and so "in theory" the mix could work as a substrate in a true hydroponic system for growing plants like tomatoes. Hydroponic substrates cannot have an organic component because it would rot and decompose due to the daily ebb and flow cycles; so they are usually pure mineral based stuff like clay balls or asbestos. For cactus growing, our "ebb and flow cycle", if you could call it that, is measured in weeks rather than times per day. So not really hydroponic but bears a resemblance hence tongue in cheek.
User avatar
jerrytheplater
Posts: 1250
Joined: Mon Mar 22, 2021 7:38 pm
Location: Bloomingdale, NJ (USDA Zone 6b)
Contact:

Re: Are you growing your cacti in a soilless mix?

Post by jerrytheplater »

AirWreck wrote: Wed Jun 12, 2024 2:22 pm so they are usually pure mineral based stuff like clay balls or asbestos.
You probably mean Rock Wool.
Jerry Smith
Bloomingdale, NJ
45 inches (114 cm) rain equivalent per year, approx. evenly spread per month
2012 USDA Hardiness Zone 6b: -5F to OF (-20C to -18C) min.
Post Reply