cacti id

[edstar500]

can anyone help id these? firstly this one:

[edstar500]

second one i would love an id for

[edstar500]

third:

[edstar500]

fourth:

[edstar500]

and finally this fifth one, which was from ikea about four years ago.

[Eleanor]

Second one I think is Notocactus scopa - I'm not an expert in the IDs, having had a fair bit of help ID-ing my collection from the wonderful folks on here, but I have one of these sat on a shelf next to me and it looks the same so figured I'd suggest it and see if I'm right!

[adetheproducer]

Is the last one Mammillaria carnea?

[DaveW]

Your second one may be Notocactus schlosseri or something similar:-

http://www.karacactus.com/cactiImagePage_C_0056.htm" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;

http://www.cactuspedia.info/schede/NOTO ... _HU491.htm" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;

It's not scopa, though that has many forms:-

http://www.cactuspedia.info/schede/NOTO ... _scopa.htm" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;

[CactusFanDan]

3. Rebutia albiflora.
5. Mammillaria karwinskiana.

[idgie]

The first one looks like an echinopsis to me. (Not sure at all.)

[vlani]

1 - 'common' Echinopsis
2 - Noto schlosserii
3 - I'd say R.fiebrigii or Sulco glomeriseta. Rebutia is a pretty common plant, Sulco is not that much. Very easy to tell once you see flowers which one it is
4 - some Parodia I think. There are a few that hard to tell apart unless they are really old and in flower.
5 is probably karwinskiana.

[edstar500]

thanks for the replies

could the top one be echinopsis mamillosa? the images that come up on a google search look pretty similar

[edstar500]

Hello, number 3 is flowering now, does this help anyone make a more positive id?

[Robb]

The yellow flower suggests that it is not Rebutia albiflora.

[greenknight]

The first one doesn't look like Echinopsis mammillosa to me - that species has tubercles in between the areoles, also tends to have more ribs than yours. My first guess would be E. oxygona, but that's just a guess - many of them look very similar.